Can Your Limited Partner Status Shield You from Self-Employment Tax?

For many years, taxpayers and practitioners have treated the phrase “limited partner” as a potential shield against self-employment tax, based on a specific section of the Internal Revenue Code. Today, that planning assumption has become significantly more complex.

Recent decisions from the Tax Court and the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals have taken highly divergent paths regarding when a limited partner’s distributive share is subject to self-employment tax. The result is growing uncertainty for partnerships, LLCs, and other flow-through entities—particularly those with owners who actively provide services to the enterprise.

The Core of the Dispute: Section 1402(a)(13)

In general, a partner’s distributive share of partnership income is included in their net earnings from self-employment. However, Internal Revenue Code Section 1402(a)(13) excludes “the distributive share of any item of income or loss of a limited partner, as such,” with the exception of guaranteed payments for services actually rendered. This carve-out can lead to substantial tax savings, given that self-employment tax generally applies at a 15.3% rate up to the Social Security wage base, plus Medicare tax and potentially an additional Medicare surtax.

The central question is simple but difficult to resolve: when is an individual truly considered a “limited partner” for self-employment tax purposes?

Tax planning and compliance challenges

Two Contrasting Court Interpretations

The confusion stems from two distinct judicial standards, creating a direct split in how these tax rules are applied.

The Tax Court’s Functional Approach

In the Soroban Capital Partners case, the Tax Court applied a functional, facts-and-circumstances analysis. The court concluded that the statutory exception in Section 1402(a)(13) was intended strictly for passive investors, not active service providers. Under this approach, the court looked beyond the formal labels in the partnership agreement and focused entirely on the partner’s actual participation in the business.

This means a partner could be classified as a limited partner under state law but still be subject to self-employment tax if the factual record shows meaningful participation in the entity’s operations.

The Fifth Circuit’s Initial and Restated Approaches

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals took a different path in the Sirius Solutions case. In its January 16, 2026, decision, the court held that a limited partner for self-employment tax purposes is simply a state-law limited partner with limited liability, rejecting the Tax Court’s passive-investor-only interpretation.

However, seven months later, in the K Alen case, the Fifth Circuit withdrew and restated its January 2026 opinion. The court shifted to a middle-ground standard that examines whether the partner plays a significant managerial role in running the business. Under this restated standard, performing services does not automatically trigger self-employment tax, but holding significant management authority can disqualify the partner from the statutory exception.

Key Factual Factors That Determine Exposure

Because the law remains unsettled, taxpayers cannot rely on the label of “limited partner” alone. Instead, the following factual elements are critical in evaluating self-employment tax risk:

  • State-law status: Is the individual legally structured as a limited partner under the entity’s governing state law?
  • Management authority: Does the partner possess the authority to manage or run the business? The Fifth Circuit’s restated standard focuses heavily on this significant managerial role.
  • Decision-making power: Does the individual vote on operational matters like budgets, hiring, compensation, strategy, or policy? Such actions point to management rather than passive investment.
  • Operational participation: Does the partner merely perform services, or do they direct personnel and control business operations? The Tax Court treats active operational participation as a major risk factor.
  • Guaranteed payments: Even if a partner successfully qualifies for the limited partner exclusion, any guaranteed payments for services rendered remain subject to self-employment tax.
  • Entity structure and documents: Partnership agreements, operating agreements, committee authority, and actual governance practices are critical. Formal titles will not protect a partner if the factual reality shows genuine control.
Partner reviewing business documents

The Impact on LLCs, LLPs, and LLLPs

Although the statutory language specifically mentions limited partners, modern enterprises frequently utilize LLCs, LLPs, and limited liability limited partnerships (LLLPs) instead of traditional limited partnerships. While members who act purely as passive investors and do not participate in management are generally exempt from self-employment tax, members who provide services are subject to tax on both their distributive share of income and any guaranteed payments.

As a result, taxpayers using these modern structures must be highly cautious, as the label of the entity does not automatically resolve the self-employment tax question.

A Geographic Patchwork of Rules

The lack of consensus among the courts has created a complex regional split across the country:

  • The Fifth Circuit (Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi): In these states, the restated Sirius Solutions / K Alain decision controls. This standard is currently more favorable to taxpayers than the Tax Court’s strict passive-investor test, but it still requires a rigorous review of managerial activity.
  • Other Regions: Outside the Fifth Circuit, the Tax Court’s Soroban approach remains the primary baseline position for IRS audits. Taxpayers in other jurisdictions face a more aggressive IRS position asserting that active service providers do not qualify for the exclusion.
  • National Implications: This judicial divergence means that taxpayers in different regions may experience different tax outcomes on identical facts. This classic circuit-split scenario increases the likelihood that the Supreme Court may eventually need to resolve the issue.

A Proactive, Conservative Strategy for Taxpayers

Until clear, nationwide guidance is established, the safest approach is to assume that the IRS may challenge any limited partner classification where the partner exhibits substantial activity. A conservative strategy should include the following steps:

  • Review the partnership agreement to confirm whether the owner truly possesses limited liability under state law.
  • Narrowly limit or remove managerial authority for any partners who expect to claim the exception.
  • Separate service compensation from distributive share income where appropriate.
  • Document specifically who has the authority to hire, fire, direct operations, approve budgets, and set policy.
  • Treat guaranteed payments as fully subject to self-employment tax.
  • Consider filing with a disclosure statement or taking a protective position if the facts are not entirely clear.
  • Reevaluate existing entity structures rather than assuming legacy partnership arrangements remain compliant.

Ultimately, if a partner is involved in running the business, the safer assumption is that self-employment tax may apply.

Navigating the Evolving Tax Landscape

The recent court rulings demonstrate that “limited partner” is no longer a simple, label-based status for self-employment tax purposes. With the Tax Court focusing on whether a partner is genuinely passive, and the Fifth Circuit examining managerial control, actual facts override formal titles.

Before treating partnership income as exempt from self-employment tax, business owners must carefully evaluate each partner’s role, authority, and compensation structure. In the current regulatory environment, a conservative, facts-first review is the most reliable defense against an IRS challenge. Contact our office today to evaluate your business structure and ensure compliance.

Share this article...

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .
Let Wastvedt and Company, Inc. remove your tax & accounting stress today.
Contact us to learn more.
Wastvedt and Company, Inc. We love to chat!
Please feel free to use the contact button or use our Ai powered chat assistant.
Please fill out the form and our team will get back to you shortly The form was sent successfully